Lead sites, directories or your own Google listing?
Your own Google Business Profile is free and brings calls that only come to you. Lead sites and booking platforms sell the same customer to several businesses, so you pay and still compete on price. Directories help a little, mostly by listing your name and number consistently. Most local businesses do best putting their effort into their own Google profile and website, and using lead sites only to fill quiet weeks.
There are plenty of ways to pay for leads. Here's an honest comparison of the three most common options.
Lead sites
You sign up, describe your work and the area, and the site sends you job requests from people who filled in a form.
The good: jobs can come in quickly, and you don't need a website.
The catch:
- You often pay per lead, whether you win the job or not
- The same lead usually goes to several businesses, so you compete on price from the start
- The customer belongs to the platform. Next time, they go back to the platform, not to you
- Your reviews live on their site, not on your own Google profile
Directories
Online business directories list your name, number and category.
The good: free listings help Google see that your business details are the same everywhere, and some people do search them.
The catch: paid upgrades rarely bring enough calls to cover the cost, and few customers start their search on a directory.
Your own Google Business Profile
The good:
- It's free
- When someone phones from it, they're phoning only you
- Reviews build up on your own profile and keep working for years
- Most local searches start on Google, where your profile shows
The catch: it takes work to get to the top three and stay there: the right setup, reviews, photos, posts and a website that matches.
What I'd do
- Make your own Google profile and website your main source of calls
- Add free listings on the main directories, with the same name, number and website
- Use lead sites only if you have gaps in your diary, and track what each lead costs you
Every call from your own profile is a customer who chose you, not one you had to outbid three others for.
A real result from a business I run Google for.
More questions
Are directory listings worth it?
Free listings on the main South African directories are worth having for consistency: the same name, number and website everywhere. Paid directory upgrades rarely pay for themselves.
Do lead sites work?
They can bring jobs, but read the pricing carefully. Many charge per lead whether you win the job or not, and send the same lead to several businesses.
What about Facebook Marketplace and community groups?
They can be good for some businesses, especially community-based ones. They're best alongside a strong Google profile, not instead of it.
Rather have me sort it out?
That's what Google Business Profile Management is for. Keep your website.
